a wired piece from last week (“Sincerely Ours: Glee’s Success Cements Age of Geeky ‘New Sincerity'”) on how irony is dead, guilty pleasures are no longer guilty, and it’s now okay to be enthusiastic about just about anything. it concludes a historical and contextual analysis with the following thought:
“Overthrowing the ironists may lead to a dictatorship of neo-sincerists. However, in this new Age of Sincerity, there is hope that we can be sincere about the things we love and hate.
Love show choir? Fine. Hate comic books? It’s a free country.
If irony has taught us anything, it’s that nothing exists in a vacuum safe from mockery. But if geeking out has taught us anything, it’s that there are 101 ways to be a nerd. It’s time we embraced all of them.”
this, i think, is the key that opens it all up. it’s not that everything is good now that we once thought was bad; or that we’re past the point of joking at the expense of what we don’t like. it’s that people find good and bad in different things for different reasons, and they’re all valid in some way (except wayans brothers movies. those are definitely exempt and not at all okay to like).
these days, what’s really important to most who might judge us is that we have passion for something. baseball or battlestar or busby berkley, who cares, as long as you show enthusiasm and knowledge and can speak interestingly on some subject under the sun.
my only question is, how do kids today have any idea who to make friends with? i was magnetically drawn to the other geeks reading lord of the rings growing up, and shunned heartily by popular kids with sports team starter jackets, and everything was easy to decode. don’t tell me that now they all go around getting to know each other as individuals… do they? that sounds exhausting.

