every time i’ve finished a book in the past few months, i’ve thought, ‘i should write something about that. i haven’t reviewed a book in ages’. then as they piled up on my desk, ‘oh man, these reviews are going to get shorter and less thoughtful and get consolidated into a “summer reading” list for sure’.
now that summer’s practically over (seriously? when did it even start, and it’s over sunday?), i guess i better do this for real. the funny thing is that most of the non-comic picks were actually terrible choices as far as fitting the classic idea of a summer read. but then again, i’ve only been to the beach three times this summer and i live in freaking southern california.
anyway, to be as concise as possible, here are three-sentence reviews and ratings of some very good books.
summer reading 2007

blood meridian – cormac mccarthy – 3 stars
this guy can write descriptive prose about a desert landscape for pages upon well-crafted pages. he really makes you feel how hellish it is, but then, by empathizing with the characters, you too just grow despondent and feel like a dried-out husk. i appreciate the talent, but wish the totally captivating judge holden got a higher page-count so it wasn’t essentially a chore with occasional violent moments of excitement.
marvel 1602 – neil gaiman – 4 stars
like my all-time favorite, the sandman, this takes existing mythologies and weaves them together in strange new ways. seeing olde tyme versions of the x-men, fantastic four, daredevil, et al on an adventure together was great fun, and the art was beautifully fitting for the setting. although i enjoyed it immensely as a gaiman fan, i can recognize that unlike sandman, the new story pulled together out of these existing threads isn’t necessarily one of his best.
god is not great – christopher hitchens – 5 stars
i could catch hell (pun!) for enjoying this as much as i did, because yes, the critics are right, this isn’t going to change anyone’s mind, it’s preaching to the choir. being the choir, however, i found its cataloguing of the myriad sins and shortcomings of religion in general to be handy fodder for conversation and an entertaining read, if not an exhaustive indictment. hitchens is a very intelligent and pithy guy, and i found myself chuckling, nodding in agreement, or gasping quite often, which as far as books go means it was a good one.
ronin – frank miller – 3 stars
one of frank miller’s earliest graphic novels, the visual and storytelling style that matured into brilliance with dark knight or sin city shows its beginnings here. the book was a thoughtful and unexpected gift from my brother for being in his wedding, so i had never heard much about it before reading it. it’s a little raw and rambling compared to his later stuff, but a nice addition to the miller section of my comics shelf.
the trial – franz kafka – 5 stars
i totally respect and adore a story that can be simple in the telling and still hold huge, profound, complex ideas. essentially an existential parable on life and death and fighting against hopelessness — at least that’s how i took it — i could say so much more but i’ll save it for next time we get deep over some late night beers. instead i’ll just share my favorite line, paraphrased since i don’t have the book in front of me: “is there no way to have a life outside the trial?”
the black dahlia – james ellroy – 4 stars
another great one only slightly clouded by expectation. the characters and story are fleshed out really well and once it picks up steam you can’t put it down from one draw-dropper to the next until it reaches its brutal finish. i guess the only problem is that part of me wants every detective story to read like chandler, whereas this is much darker and seems to take less joy in itself; only a minor personal tick against an otherwise fantastic book.